The National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) has argued that the High Court should sentence convicted murderer Ayanda Dayi to five life terms plus 76 years’ direct imprisonment when he returns to court for sentencing this week, reports Cape {town} Etc.
Dayi was convicted by the circuit court sitting at the Wynberg Regional Court on four counts of murder, one count of attempted murder, two counts of robbery with aggravating circumstances, theft, as well as multiple counts relating to the illegal possession of firearms and ammunition.
The convictions stem from a series of violent incidents that unfolded over several months in 2024, including a brazen attack on a Sasko bread delivery truck in Delft that gained nationwide attention.
According to the NPA, Dayi’s violent crime spree began on 24 January 2024 in Du Noon, where two men – Eric Yaphi and Elvis Thembelani Cwethiso – were fatally shot and robbed of their vehicle.
Days later, police located the stolen vehicle in Delft. Forensic evidence linked a firearm recovered from the vehicle to the murders, while Dayi’s fingerprints were also found inside.
The case gained national attention following the fatal shooting of two bread delivery workers, Xolani Gaji and Cebisile Mfundiso, at a spaza shop on the corner of Delft Main Road and Symphony Way on 16 May 2024. A third victim, Aphiwer Nogaya, survived the attack after undergoing surgery.
Surveillance footage presented in court showed two armed men approaching the truck before opening fire and point-blank range. Nogaya later identified Dayi in a photo parade and in court. A forensic analyst from SAPS’ Local Criminal Record Centre confirmed, through facial identification analysis, that Dayi was the gunman captured in the footage.
Senior State Advocate Esna Erasmus, who led the prosecution, argued in aggravation of sentence that the families of the four deceased victims ‘received death sentences at the hands of the accused,’ adding that they were condemned to ‘a different kind of life sentence, one of permanent grief, unanswered questions, trauma, nightmares and irreplaceable loss’.
The State further highlighted Dayi’s criminal history. He has previous convictions for robbery and rape, for which he was sentenced to 18 years’ direct imprisonment. He was released on parole in April 2018 and was due to complete his sentence in July 2025.
The NPA contended that his reoffending while on conditional release demonstrates a blatant disregard for the law and for the leniency previously extended to him.
In its submission, the State argued that five of the offences attract prescribed minimum sentences of life imprisonment and that there are no substantial and compelling circumstances that would justify a deviation from these sentences.
The gravity and multiplicity of these convictions underscore the sustained and calculated nature of his criminal conduct,’ the NPA said in its statement.
The prosecution further maintained that Dayi has shown no remorse and continues to maintain his innocence despite what it described as overwhelming evidence.
‘All these factors point to one unavoidable conclusion: the accused poses a high risk of future violent conduct,’ the statement continued.
The High Court will hand down sentencing at 10am on Tuesday, 24 February 2026 at the circuit court sitting at Wynberg Regional Court.
Also read:
Three shot dead in Dunoon as police investigate brutal killings
Picture: WAAR Brandit INNI KAAP / Facebook





